AI VEndor Evaluation Resources for Independent Agents.

Equip your agency to make informed, strategic technology decisions. This resource hub from the Agents Council for Technology (ACT) gives your agency a clear path forward — helping you prepare, ask smarter questions, and confidently evaluate AI solutions that align with your goals.

Resources.


20 Smart Questions to Ask When Evaluating AI Tools

For independent insurance agencies evaluating AI tools

Download PDF

AI Vendor Evaluation – Complete Checklist

Quick reference for must-haves in AI solutions for independent agencies.

Download PDF

Five Steps to Take Before You Engage with Vendors

Preparing your business for smarter tech decisions.

Download PDF

AI Glossary of Terms

Glossary of technical terms.

Download List

Looking for specific vendor information?

Check out Catalyit’s Solution Provider Directory!

PREPARING YOUR BUSINESS FOR SMARTER TECH DECISIONS

5 Steps To Take Before You Engage With Vendors.

1.Clarify Your Business Goals & Growth Plan


Update your business plan to reflect current and future goals

Set 3–5 year targets for revenue, premium volume, and headcount

Define your target book of business now and in the future (e.g., PL vs. CL, Life, Health, Benefits)

2. Assess Your Current Tech Stack


List all current technologies in use and rate their value to your operations

Identify underutilized tools and areas for improvement

Document costs and note which could be eliminated with better-integrated solutions

Determine your budget for new tech and support— include both upfront and recurring costs

3. Evaluate Internal Readiness


Survey your team to understand what’s working and where pain points exist

Be transparent with your team—share that change may be coming and invite their input

Review KPIs to see where inefficiencies lie (e.g., hit ratios, lead response, hold times, NPS)

Define your target book of business now and in the future (e.g., PL vs. CL, Life, Health, Benefits)

4. Start Thinking About AI


Define your agency’s vision—how do you want to show up to clients and staff in an AI-powered world?

Start educating yourself through podcasts, webinars, your Big “I” state association, and ACT

Be honest about team readiness—are you equipped to adopt AI or still exploring?

Begin drafting internal AI guidelines and involve legal to address risk and compliance

Recognize that team members may already be using AI tools—bring that usage into the open and shape policy accordingly

5. Align Internally Before Moving Forward


Identify which business processes will be impacted or need to change with new tech

Clarify the goals you want the technology to support—avoid “tech for tech’s sake”

Create a simple change management plan to guide employee engagement during future implementation

Begin gathering referrals from peers, state associations, and ACT to inform future vendor conversations

Start thinking about ROI— what outcomes matter most (efficiency, growth, client experience)?

Glossary of Technical Terms.


  • Artificial Intelligence (AI): The simulation of human intelligence processes by machines, including learning, reasoning, and self-correction.
  • Bias in AI: Systematic errors in AI outputs caused by biased training data or flawed algorithms, which can lead to unfair or inaccurate results.
  • Encryption in Transit and at Rest: Encryption in transit protects data while it is being transmitted. Encryption at rest protects data stored on a device or server.
  • Explainability: The degree to which an AI system’s decisions can be understood and interpreted by humans.
  • Generative AI: AI that can create new content such as text, images, or music based on training data.
  • GLBA: Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act, a U.S. law that requires financial institutions to explain how they share and protect customers’ private information.
  • HIPAA: Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act, a U.S. law that protects sensitive patient health information.
  • Inference: The process of using a trained AI model to make predictions or generate outputs based on new input data.
  • ISO 27001: An international standard for managing information security.
  • Large Language Model (LLM): A type of AI model trained on vast amounts of text data to understand and generate human-like language (e.g., ChatGPT, Claude).
  • Machine Learning (ML): A subset of AI that enables systems to learn from data and improve performance over time without being explicitly programmed.
  • Model Hallucination: When an AI generates incorrect or fabricated information that appears plausible.
  • Natural Language Processing (NLP): A branch of AI that helps computers understand, interpret, and generate human language.
  • Predictive AI: AI that analyzes data to make predictions about future outcomes.
  • Prompt Engineering: The practice of crafting effective inputs (prompts) to guide AI models toward desired outputs.
  • Rule-based AI: AI that operates based on a set of predefined rules and logic.
  • SLAs: Service Level Agreements, which define the level of service expected from a vendor, including uptime and response times.
  • SOC 2 Type II: A certification that evaluates an organization’s information systems relevant to security, availability, processing integrity, confidentiality, and privacy over a period of time.
  • Training Data: The dataset used to teach an AI model how to perform tasks or make predictions.

20 Smart Questions To Ask For Independent Insurance Agencies Evaluating AI Tools.


Fit & Functionality

  1. What specific problems does this tool solve for independent insurance agencies?
  2. Is it customizable to our workflows or limited to preset processes?
  3. Does it integrate with our AMS, CRM, or other systems? Or ability in the future?
  4. Can you provide use cases from other independent agencies?

Security, Privacy & Compliance

  1. Do you have SOC 2 Type II or ISO 27001 certification?
  2. Who owns the data — especially AI-generated data? Are there data retention and deletion policies I can control?
  3. Do you share data with third parties for training or analytics?
  4. If you leverage an AI (e.g., OpenAI, Claude, Gemini) Do you have agreements with model providers regarding data usage and training?
  1. What’s included in your pricing — and what costs extra? Are there long-term contracts or cancellation fees? Does the contract include a termination clause within 6 months if performance is unsatisfactory (with the expectation that the agency is ready to use and do their part).
  2. Can I export my data if we choose to stop using your service?
  3. What SLAs, indemnification, or cybersecurity liability terms are included?
  4. Is there a trial period available for evaluation?
  5. Have they demonstrated the top 3-5 problems this solution addresses specifically for your agency?

Implementation & Support

  1. When can implementation begin, and how long will it take?
  2. What kind of onboarding support and role-based training do you provide? Is there a dedicated account manager or support team post-launch?
  3. What happens after launch — do you offer optimization or ongoing check-ins?
  4. Can the vendor help develop internal AI usage policies for your agency? (Bonus)

(Check-In Questions)

Post-Implementation

  1. Are we hitting the metrics or outcomes we expected (e.g., reduced time, higher retention)?
  2. What feedback are we hearing from staff and clients?
  3. Has the vendor followed up to support optimization or performance review?
  4. Are we using the full capabilities of the platform — or underutilizing it?

This list is provided for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Please conduct your own due diligence when evaluating vendors or entering into any agreements.